Shelter Dog Meal Donation Count:

Learn More

9 Signs Your Dog Is Trying to Outsmart You

By: Arlene Divina
Arlene Divina, one of the content writers at IHD, loves going on adventures with her adorable fur baby. She now creates informative content for pet parents. Read more
| September 17, 2024

Shutterstock

Dogs are highly intelligent animals, often surprising us with their ability to outsmart their humans. While they depend on us for food, shelter, and care, many dogs show cleverness in getting what they want or avoiding what they don’t. Whether it’s sneaking treats, dodging bath time, or bending the rules, dogs use various tricks to stay one step ahead. If you’ve ever felt outwitted by your dog, you’re not alone—dogs frequently display problem-solving skills that make us wonder if they’re intentionally trying to outsmart us.

Selective Hearing

Shutterstock

Have you ever called your dog only for them to completely ignore you—unless you mention their favorite word like “treat” or “walk”? This behavior can be a sign that your dog is practicing selective hearing. They know when you’re calling them for something fun versus something they’d rather avoid, like bath time or going to the vet. When your dog selectively listens, they’re showing a keen understanding of which commands benefit them and which don’t. This selective response isn’t just stubbornness; it’s a clever way for your dog to avoid doing things they don’t enjoy.

Mastering the Art of Distraction

Shutterstock

Some dogs are masters at diverting your attention when they want something. For example, if your dog has learned that barking at the door gets you to look away from your dinner plate, they may use that trick to grab a quick bite while you’re distracted. Dogs are quick learners, and once they figure out that creating a distraction works in their favor, they’ll use it repeatedly to get what they want. Whether it’s pretending to bark at something outside or nudging a toy to divert your attention, these dogs know how to outsmart you by causing distractions.

Pretending Not to Understand Commands

Shutterstock

If your dog is highly trained but sometimes pretends not to understand simple commands like “sit” or “stay,” they might be trying to outsmart you. Dogs know that if they can get away with ignoring commands, they might not have to follow through with tasks they find boring or unnecessary. Pretending not to understand is a clever way to test your boundaries and see what they can get away with. This tactic often works when owners give up after repeating the command, allowing the dog to skip the task entirely.

Knowing How to Play the Guilt Card

Shutterstock

Dogs are experts at using their expressive eyes and body language to make us feel guilty. Whether it’s giving you those big, sad puppy eyes when you leave the house or acting extra pitiful when they want a treat, dogs know how to pull at your heartstrings. They quickly learn that by acting sad or needy, they can get what they want—whether it’s extra attention, food, or a longer play session. This emotional manipulation is a sign that your dog understands how to read your emotions and use them to their advantage, making them expert at outsmarting their humans.

Understanding Routine Loopholes

Shutterstock

Dogs thrive on routine, but some clever dogs figure out how to use routines to their advantage. For example, if your dog knows that after dinner comes playtime, they might try to speed up dinner or feign hunger to get to playtime faster. Similarly, dogs who understand that certain behaviors lead to specific rewards will manipulate situations to trigger those rewards. These dogs are not only smart but also observant, using their knowledge of routines to subtly manipulate you into giving them what they want sooner rather than later.

Using Toys or Objects to Communicate

Shutterstock

Have you ever noticed your dog bringing you a leash when they want to go for a walk or dropping a toy in your lap to signal playtime? While this might seem cute, it’s also a sign that your dog is using tools to communicate and outsmart you. Dogs who learn how to use objects to convey their desires show a high level of problem-solving ability. By directly showing you what they want, they bypass the need to bark or whine, making it harder for you to say no to their requests.

Learning to Open Doors or Gates

Shutterstock

Some dogs go above and beyond to outsmart their humans by physically manipulating their environment. If your dog has figured out how to open doors, gates, or even cabinets, they’re demonstrating advanced problem-solving skills. Whether it’s to sneak into rooms they’re not allowed in or to get to food, dogs who learn how to manipulate their surroundings are using their intelligence to bypass obstacles. This level of cleverness shows that your dog isn’t just following commands—they’re actively thinking about how to achieve their goals, even if it means breaking the rules.

Faking Behaviors for Rewards

Shutterstock

Has your dog ever pretended to do something just to get a reward? For example, some dogs will fake being asleep to avoid getting in trouble or pretend to be obedient when they know a treat is coming. This deceptive behavior is a clear sign that your dog is trying to outsmart you. They understand that by appearing to follow the rules or acting in a certain way, they can manipulate situations in their favor. Dogs who fake behaviors are highly intelligent and know how to play the game to get what they want.

Manipulating Playtime to Their Advantage

Shutterstock

During playtime, some dogs take control by subtly manipulating the game to keep it going longer or to win more often. For example, dogs who love fetch might “accidentally” drop the ball farther away, forcing you to chase it, or they may run just slow enough for you to catch up and play longer. This clever manipulation during play shows that your dog is thinking strategically, using play as an opportunity to outsmart you and extend the fun. These dogs are not just playing—they’re crafting a game plan that keeps them in control of the fun.

Your Clever Dog, Always One Step Ahead

Shutterstock

Dogs are often more intelligent than we give them credit for, and their clever behaviors show they’re constantly thinking and strategizing. From pretending not to hear commands to using distractions and subtle manipulation, dogs have many ways to outsmart their humans. While these actions can be frustrating, they’re also a testament to your dog’s problem-solving skills. Recognizing the signs that your dog is outsmarting you can help you better understand their thinking process—and maybe even find ways to stay one step ahead, though that might not be easy!